Connect with us


Some Assisted-Living Residents Don’t Get Promised Care, Suit Charges



The letter went out to about 1,900 Californians a few weeks ago from law firms bringing a class-action suit against one of the country’s largest assisted-living chains.

If the recipients, or their family members, had lived in a community operated by Sunrise Senior Living in recent years, “we would like to speak with you regarding your residency and experience,” the letter said.

It was the latest action in an ongoing campaign: Since 2013, a group of law firms has systematically sued several major chains operating in the state, employing an unusual strategy.

“It all boils down to the use of assessments, or lack thereof,” said Kathryn Stebner, the trial counsel in the case. “These are à la carte facilities — the more needs you have, the more you have to pay. So, they assess you.”

The plaintiffs’ complaint, filed in 2017 and now before the U.S. District Court for Central California, argues that when staff members conduct such periodic assessments — to determine whether a resident needs help bathing or dressing, for example, or suffers from dementia — the facilities don’t use the results to determine an adequate number of staff members.

Instead, the plaintiffs argue, administrators make staffing decisions financially, based on budgets and return on investment. When assessments show increasing needs, the suit alleges, fees rise but staffing ratios may not change.

“People pay more, but they’re not getting more care,” Ms. Stebner said.

The suit claims that Sunrise is misrepresenting its practices and deceiving customers, in violation of state business statutes, and lacks enough trained staff members to deliver the care specified in resident contracts and marketing materials.

“The business model is fraudulent, and it’s putting people at risk,” Ms. Stebner said.

Sunrise’s practices are unlawful in another way, as well, the suit charges. “If you take an elder’s property, knowing it could harm them, that’s financial elder abuse,” Ms. Stebner said. “In this case, they’re taking their money.”

In an emailed statement, Sunrise denounced “baseless lawsuits like these, in which the plaintiffs’ lawyers file copycat allegations,” a reference to the firms having brought four previous suits using essentially the same tactics. Sunrise called the claims “categorically false.”

The lawyers’ scorecard to date: two settlements reached in 2016, totaling $13 million from Emeritus Corporation (since merged with Brookdale Senior Living) and $6.4 million from Atria Senior Living.

Suits against two other chains, Aegis Living and Oakmont Senior Living, will proceed when and if courts certify them as class actions. The Sunrise case, with a “purported class” of 13,000 current and former residents in California, also awaits certification. (A smaller group received the letters asking for information.)

But in the meantime, the plaintiffs have compelled the chain, with 268 facilities across the country and 52 in California, to turn over a trove of documents showing how it determines staffing levels.

Sunrise argued that those were “protected trade secrets.” The judge disagreed. Given that this is an industry whose practices often remain opaque, that might constitute a victory in itself for the plaintiffs.

“It gets at internal systemic issues,” said Eric Carlson, a directing attorney at Justice in Aging, a legal advocacy group not involved in the lawsuits. When facilities disclose information like how much time staff members spend on tasks, “it gets at what’s happening behind closed doors.”

Are assisted-living facilities understaffed? It’s a common complaint from residents and families, but one difficult to document.

“We don’t have a very clear picture of what staff looks like in assisted living,” said Kali Thomas, a health services researcher at the Brown University School of Public Health.

“We don’t know what an individual assisted living’s staff ratios are. Many states don’t even require them to track or report them.”

Offering a less institutional environment for seniors who require help with the so-called activities of daily living — but don’t need round-the-clock care in a nursing home — the assisted-living industry can house close to a million people in almost 30,000 facilities nationwide.

It includes both small four-bed care homes and complexes with more than 100 residents, but chains dominate the field. And the industry has staved off the kind of regulations that make it much easier to see what’s going on — for better or worse — in nursing homes.

Though Medicaid pays for a small but growing proportion of residents, assisted living remains primarily a private-pay option. (The average cost last year, in one annual survey: $4,051 a month nationally, and $4,500 in California.)

The lack of federal dollars helps explain why assisted living is subject not to federal oversight, like nursing homes, but to state regulations, which vary wildly.

Colorado, for instance, requires that an assisted-living facility employs one aide per 10 residents during the day, and one to 16 at night. In Missouri, it’s one to 15, and one to 25. Only 19 states specify minimum staffing ratios at all.

Families can find it difficult to make informed decisions about assisted living; there’s no equivalent of the federal inspection findings and quality rankings at Nursing Home Compare. State websites are inadequate substitutes, a recent study found.

Yet the people moving into these complexes need more help than they did years ago.

“They’re older,” Ms. Thomas pointed out. “They’re entering with more chronic diseases.” More than 40 percent have moderate or severe dementia, a study in the journal Health Affairs reported.

The California lawsuits don’t seek individual damages, and because the classes involved contain thousands of individuals, their checks from settlements so far have been paltry — a few hundred dollars each.

But the suits also seek “injunctive relief,” a court-ordered requirement that the defendants change their practices.

“They’d be told to be transparent,” Ms. Stebner said. “We want them to use the assessments properly and to tell people what they’re doing. And to have sufficient staff.”

Veteran researchers sounded more skeptical about the lawsuits’ impact. Understaffing represents “a complaint about long-term care in general,” said Dr. Philip Sloane, a geriatrician at the University of North Carolina School of Medicine. “Of course it’s true. The question is, what is realistic?”

“These places do set very high expectations,” said Sheryl Zimmerman, a health services researcher at the University of North Carolina School of Social Work. “Everyone’s website sounds like Utopia.”

But she added, “These group settings cannot individualize everything for every person.” Being forced to add staff members could make assisted living even more expensive, unreachable for many older adults, she said.


Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Not the best but, I wanted to do this pose right as I awoke 寝起きにいきなりやる気になった まだまだ…



Not the best but, I wanted to do this pose right as I awoke🎀🌸🐽🧠

#ヨガ講師 #ダイエット
#yoga #yogaphotography
#yogalove #yogadaily #yogapose #iloveyoga #igyoga #yogaeverydamnday #yogagirl #yogi #yogini #pincha
#asana #yogaeveryday #fit #yogafam
#yogaaddict #yogainstructor


Continue Reading


Vaping Illnesses May Have Many Americans Quitting E-Cigs



FRIDAY, Feb. 21, 2020 (HealthDay News) — New research suggests that last summer’s spate of severe lung illnesses tied to vaping prompted many Americans to consider giving up e-cigarettes.

Online searches about how to quit vaping spiked after serious lung injuries among vapers started being reported, the study authors found

As of January, more than 2,700 hospitalizations for vaping-associated lung injury had been reported in the United States. Sixty deaths in 27 states have been confirmed, with more under investigation, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Before these lung illness cases were connected primarily with vaping of marijuana and additives, many people who used nicotine-containing e-cigarettes were concerned, the researchers noted.

“We were curious whether this outbreak led vapers to consider stopping using e-cigarettes or increased people’s desire to quit,” said study author Dr. Sara Kalkhoran, an investigator in the Tobacco Research and Treatment Center at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.

“We thought people might be going to the internet to look into ways to help them quit,” Kalkhoran added in a hospital news release.

She and her team analyzed Google data and found that searches with terms such as “quit vaping” increased up to 3.7-fold during the lung illness outbreak.

“Then these searches then died down, so the timing of the outbreak was strongly associated with searches on how to get off of these products,” Kalkhoran said.

This suggests that public health officials and health care providers need to provide stronger messages about vaping, the researchers said.

Also, health care providers need to ask patients specifically about vaping, since “people who vape may not think of themselves as smoking. People are looking into quitting these products, so we need to be able to screen in a context where we can actually help them clinically and they don’t have to go to the internet for information,” Kalkhoran said.

The study was published recently in the Journal of General Internal Medicine.

— Robert Preidt

Copyright © 2020 HealthDay. All rights reserved.


What is the average weight gain for those who quit smoking?
See Answer


SOURCE: Massachusetts General Hospital, news release, Feb. 13, 2020


Continue Reading


“Intentions” || Justin Bieber (feat. Quevo) || Dance Fitness || REFIT® Revolution



IT’S A REFIT DUDE TAKEOVER featuring the Husbands of REFIT!

Justin Bieber stole our hearts (again) with his latest single, “Intentions” and from the second we heard the lyrics, we knew the choreography had to include a cameo from our significant others! If these guys can learn the choreography — ANYONE CAN (trust us) — and the simplistic, repetitive movements will catapult aspiring TikTokers to instant fame! Please leave some love for the Husbands of REFIT for their willingness to step out of comfort zones and onto center stage — and don’t forget to check out Catherine’s hot date!

ARE YOU UP FOR A #REFITLOVEBIRDS CHALLENGE? Upload you and your boo dancing to these moves and one of you will win a REFIT DUDE shirt! Make sure to TAG @REFITREV and use the hashtag #REFITLOVEBIRDS XOXO, Angela, Catherine & Emily


Did you recently upgrade your TV game? Our YT channel is now showing 4K videos for the clearest picture ever!

📩Join our email list so that you’ll be the FIRST to know about new YOUTUBE videos + sales + news + REFIT events in your area:

90 minute experience class 👉
One-day instructor training 👉

“Intentions” by Justin Bieber is available for download on all social media platforms including iTunes, Spotify and Google Play.






REFIT® believes that finding a positive workout shouldn’t be a negative experience. Visit our website to access unlimited streaming workouts, find live events, and learn how you can become a certified instructor.


Continue Reading


Мы используем cookie-файлы для наилучшего представления нашего сайта. Продолжая использовать этот сайт, вы соглашаетесь с использованием cookie-файлов.